Move Over Pie! Fat and Weird Cookie’s Thanksgiving Pack Deserves the Spotlight

The most enticing thing about Thanksgiving is that the whole house smells like roasted turkey, buttery stuffing, and sweet cinnamon pies (my favorite). At this time of the year, my table glows with dishes that remind comfort, love, and celebration. However,  there is one thing that makes my Thanksgiving even more special, it’s the dessert. Desserts hold a special place on Thanksgiving. After all the savory dishes, that first bite of something sweet feels magical. From apple pies to cheesecakes, the dessert spread always brings a smile. 

While pumpkin and pecan pies are the stars of many dinner tables, trying something different that is absolutely delicious is the idea I always appreciate. So, as a cookie lover, I’m going to add some delicious cookies to my Thanksgiving table. It may sound strange for many, but cookies in particular have that homely charm that pie can’t quite capture. The best thing is they are easy to share, perfect with coffee, and ideal for those who want a sweet treat without committing to a full slice of pie. 

To capture the taste of the season, trying delicious cookies is almost the tastiest idea. You can surprise your family with a different dessert. Something that isn’t traditional, but still has that nostalgic, fall-inspired warmth with Fat and Weird Cookie’s Thanksgiving Pack. Yes, I stumbled upon the Fat and Weird Cookie Thanksgiving Pack, a limited-edition box of cookies inspired by the very essence of Thanksgiving flavor that takes things to a whole new level. Just reading the names made me hungry. Once they arrived, sealed neatly and smelling divine, I knew I had found the perfect dessert. Honestly, it turned my holiday into a flavor-filled celebration.

The Flavors of Thanksgiving in Every Bite

The Thanksgiving Pack comes with four cookies, each one unique and inspired by classic holiday flavors. The first cookie I tried was Couch Tater. Believe me, it's amazing, a sweet potato pie cookie base loaded with pecans and a gooey marshmallow core, topped with crunchy streusel. The moment I took a bite, the mix of textures, the softness of the cookie, the nutty crunch, and the creamy center was pure heaven.

The second one, MJ’s Granola Pie, which honestly tasted like nostalgia baked into a cookie. It has a shortbread base with pecans and chocolate chips, stuffed with gooey granola pie filling. It reminded me of being at my grandma’s kitchen table, surrounded by warmth and laughter. The flavors are rich, sweet, and comforting, and it’s no surprise that this one’s inspired by a family recipe.

Next up, Me So Corny, and this one completely surprised me. It’s a sweet cornbread cookie base with a honey butter frosting core, topped with sugar-coated honey Chex cereal. It tasted like the perfect blend of dessert and breakfast. The cornbread flavor gave it that Southern charm, and the honey butter center made it melt in my mouth.

Lastly, I tried Cheesecake & Chill, a pumpkin spice cookie stuffed with frosted pumpkin rolls and a cheesecake frosting core. Rolled in Turbinado sugar, it was perfectly balanced, sweet, creamy, and slightly tangy from the cheesecake. It’s the kind of dessert you want to enjoy with a warm blanket and a cup of cider after dinner.

Why Fat and Weird Cookie’s Thanksgiving Pack

What I love most about Fat and Weird Cookie is how much care goes into their treats. Each cookie is handcrafted, sealed for freshness, and filled with creativity. The brand believes that cookies aren’t just desserts—they are moments meant to be shared with friends and family, so I served them after Thanksgiving dinner. Instead of slicing pies, everyone got to pick their favorite cookie flavor, warm it up in the oven, and enjoy it with coffee.

Buy Now

The most appreciable thing is the versatility; you can eat them fresh out of the box. No problem if you warm them for a gooey bite, or freeze them for later, they still taste amazing. The cookies stay soft for weeks and can even last for months when frozen, making them a perfect make-ahead dessert for the holidays.

A Cozy Alternative to Traditional Desserts

Thanksgiving desserts usually revolve around pies, but this year, I realized that cookies deserve just as much love. The Fat and Weird Cookie Thanksgiving Pack feels like a fun, modern twist on tradition. The flavors still capture everything we love about Thanksgiving—sweet potatoes, pumpkin spice, honey butter, and pecans—but in a way that feels fresh and exciting.

The best thing is that you make a perfect gift. If you are visiting family or want to send a surprise to someone you love, these cookies come beautifully packaged and ready to enjoy. I even froze a few and reheated them on a quiet Sunday morning weeks later, and they tasted just as good.

Making Thanksgiving Sweeter with Fat and Weird Cookie

The best part about these cookies is how they bring joy to the simplest moments. After a long day of cooking and laughing, there’s something special about ending the night with a soft, warm cookie that tastes like home. The Thanksgiving Pack by Fat and Weird Cookie does exactly that—it wraps up the comfort of the season in each bite.

From the playful flavor names to the rich ingredients and creative combinations, every cookie feels like it was baked with love and imagination. Whether you’re a fan of classic desserts or just want to try something new this Thanksgiving, this pack is absolutely worth it.

As someone who has always loved experimenting with holiday desserts, I can honestly say this year felt extra sweet thanks to Fat and Weird Cookie. It’s a reminder that sometimes, the best memories come from trying something a little different—and sharing it with people who matter most.

So, if you are ready to add a fun twist to your Thanksgiving dessert table, skip the pies this time and go for something uniquely delightful. The Fat and Weird Cookie Thanksgiving Pack isn’t just dessert—it’s a celebration of flavor, creativity, and the joy of the season.

This Thanksgiving, treat yourself and your loved ones to something that’ll make everyone smile—and trust me, one bite is all it takes to fall in love.

The Fat and Weird Cookie has an affiliate program, and we are affiliated with them. As an affiliate partner, I’m excited to share these delicious cookies with you. Just click on the following link and grab a discount on your next purchase. We may earn a small commission at no extra cost to you. 

Stay tuned to FreshFads to explore more exciting flavors of cookies for having the best Thanksgiving treat.